Sunday, August 12, 2018
Don't forget your morning flax.
More than a hundred studies have shown that eating more fruits and vegetables decreases your odds of a heart attack, stroke, cancer, and early death. And the more vegetables you eat, the more pronounced the benefit.
What is the mysterious health factor associated with vegetables? It could be the simple fact that as we fill up with low fat vegetables we eat less red meat. Or maybe it is the plant antioxidants protecting us from the pesticides and other harmful chemicals in our environment. The answer, it appears, is much less glamorous - it is the extra fiber.
Fiber is the structural skeleton of all fruits, vegetables, nuts, and beans. Fiber is a carbohydrate (a starch) but unlike flour and other dietary carbohydrates, it is impervious to our digestive enzymes. And as a result this fiber passes unchanged into our colon where it is digested as a source of energy by our microbiome (the millions of resident bacteria).
There are 2 kinds of fiber.
Insoluble fiber absorbs water but won’t dissolve in it. Put a teaspoon of bran in a glass of water and you can see for yourself. The “bulk” of the indigestible fiber in our diet resistants digestion by the microbiome, passing through the colon unchanged. Its benefit is in keeping our stool bulky, helping maintain regular elimination.
Soluble fiber, on the other hand, will dissolve in water and is a “food” used by the microbiome. Various fatty acids formed as a byproduct of this bacterial metabolism are absorbed into the bloodstream and are thought to be the real reason dietary fiber is so beneficial to our health.
These fatty acids appear to affect various metabolic processes. For example, aiding in the control of blood sugar levels (diabetes) and helping to lower blood cholesterol and fat levels. Other fatty acids make it only as far as the colon lining cells where they are used by the cells themselves and thus keep the lining of our colon healthy.
Put mice on a low fiber diet and their colon lining cells shrink in size and produce less mucus. A thinning of the mucus barrier lining the colon in turn allows bacteria closer contact with the lining cells themselves. This triggers an inflammatory response as our immune system works to “protect” us from an invasion of foreign bacteria.
It has been speculated that this ongoing inflammation may play a role in the development of colon cancer. And may be the explanation of the association of a high fiber diet with a decrease in colon cancer risk.
Chronic colon inflammation may also play a role in other inflammatory conditions such as arthritis and asthma, as well as interfering with normal sugar metabolism (diabetes) and also how we store excess dietary calories. It appears to shunt these extra calories directly into fat cell storage contributing to obesity.
By providing energy to the colon bacteria, soluble fiber keeps our microbiome (those millions of bacterial factories in the colon) healthy and productive.
When mice are put on a low fiber diet, the total bacterial population quickly drops to a tenth of its pre-diet size along with experiencing a significant decrease in bacterial diversity. The result? Fewer and possibly less efficient factories to produce those helpful fatty acids.
Thus soluble fiber has two benefits. It provides the raw materials for fatty acid production and is a source of energy to keep the bacterial production facilities open and available.
What are your options to tap into fibers’ benefits? Increasing the amount of fruit and vegetables in your daily diet is the easiest start. This will not only add additional fiber but indirectly decrease the amount of red meat.
While you are working to diversify your diet, consider adding a tablespoon of flax meal (in applesauce) to your morning vitamin routine, or to your breakfast smoothie. We know this simple step works as diabetics taking a tablespoon of flax meal a day dropped their fasting blood sugars and a subgroup with high blood pressure also experienced a drop in their average readings.
A single change as you take action to improve your health. A small step, but in an important direction. Then in the late afternoon you can add a snack on a couple raw carrots or broccoli as you make dinner.
http://www.drmirkin.com/nutrition/how-soluble-fiber-promotes-good-gut-bacteria.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/01/science/food-fiber-microbiome-inflammation.html
Added after publication:
https://nutritionfacts.org/video/benefits-of-flax-seeds-for-inflammation/
Monday, July 2, 2018
Eat your way to a healthier, longer life.
The expression “you are what you eat” was coined in the late 1800s and implied that one’s state of mind was influenced by their diet . An advertisement in 1923 upped the ante when it suggested that “"ninety percent of the diseases known to man are caused by cheap foodstuffs.”
Last year a more rigorous scientific approach published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2608221) concluded that fully half of the 700,000 annual deaths from heart disease, stroke (which along with cancer are 2 of the 3 leading causes of death), and diabetes are a direct result of poor dietary habits.
The analysis found that a deficiency of healthy foods contributed as much to a poor health outcome as did an excess of unhealthy foods. Let’s take a look at the 10 diet changes they suggest would have the biggest impact.
Salt was at the top of the list of things to avoid. If you are looking for one single dietary change to improve your health, take the salt shaker off the dinner table along with cutting recipe recommendations for salt in half. It will take a couple weeks to adapt to this change, but you will soon realize how much unneeded salt is added to restaurant meals and those processed foods you are buying at the grocery store.
Sugar, especially in sodas, was number two. Along with salt, sugar is the one additive that takes a 2 week commitment to break what is a real taste addiction for many.
Processed meats, which are high in both salt and fat, were high on the “to be avoided” list.
And finally, as you might have suspected, red meat rounded out the 4 items to be avoided.
Now let’s switch to the foods that are often in short supply in our diets and, if increased, would have a positive impact on our health.
Fish, with its omega-3 fatty acids provides a great alternative to red meat. A win-win diet change, decreasing red meat while adding the omega-3s.
Also expected we tend to scrimp on our daily intake of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. When you cut down on red meat, these offer great alternatives to assure you don’t leave the table hungry.
Fats, of course, made the list. A separate study published last month, re-emphasized the cardiovascular disease (CVD) risks of “trans” as well as saturated fats. The study quoted from prior papers indicating that merely replacing dietary saturated fats with polyunsaturated vegetable oil reduced CVD by 30%.
Nuts, loaded with unsaturated (good) fats, were the final “must add” with a strong association with good outcomes. When you get that urge for a few chips and doritos between meals, a hand-full of nuts is a healthy alternative to get you to your next meal.
Another study indicated that adding just five tablespoons of olive oil or 30 g (a handful) of unsalted nuts to a conventional Mediterranean diet provided a 30% reduction in the risk of CVD mortality compared with simply lowering saturated fat intake alone.
So that rounds out ten changes to consider in your daily diet.
If you have been reading my columns the past year, this study confirms the major themes of prior articles.
- Less sugar. More and more the evidence indicates it is more harmful to your health than either salt or fats.
- Less red meat. And replace it with an increase in whole grain and vegetable side dishes. Both changes support a healthier microbiome with all its benefits.
- Less saturated and more poly-unsaturated fats. Cook with unsaturated vegetable oil (or olive oil). Get a jar of unsalted nuts for snacks. They are the answer to killing that urge to snack.
- And finally, the more you can do cook a meal yourself, avoiding restaurant and processed foods from the store, the more successful you will be in limiting your weekly intake of salt, sugar, and harmful saturated fats.
https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/39/17/1503/4987029
Eggs TMAO and cancer/heart disease: https://nutritionfacts.org/2020/08/13/what-explains-the-egg-cancer-connection/
Tuesday, June 12, 2018
Give your baby's genes a boost.
A full 50 years before Darwin published his theory of natural selection, Lamarck theorized that an organism would pass on environmental adaptations to its offspring. If you cut the tails off three or four generations of mice, you’d soon see a few tail-less babies.
Darwin, on the other hand, felt that our genes were hardwired and inherited unchanged from our parents. And then passed unchanged to our kids. Life experiences did not affect future generations. You could cut off as many mouse tails as you’d like, but would never see tail-less mice in future litters.
This assumption of a hard-wired inheritance ruled the science of genetics for over a hundred years. However, the last few decades have seen a shift in this absolutist view. Why are two identical twins (exactly the same genetic makeup or genotype) often slightly different in appearance (phenotype)?
The study of differences in genetic expression, that is how identical genes are turned on, off, or are somewhere in between, is called epigenetics. A specific cell protein, miRNA, seems to be the switch that impacts how our hardwired genetic code is interpreted. And lifestyle has been shown to directly impact cell miRNA levels.
A recently published study on brain physiology shows the link between the increase in miRNA levels in the brains of regularly exercised mice and a corresponding increase in brain nerve cell connections. This was not unexpected as we knew from prior investigations that the level of our exercise directly correlates with brain health.
Surprisingly the researchers also found the same increase in miRNA levels in the sperm of the exercising group as well as improved brain development in their offspring. (It is fair to assume that the same miRNA changes occurred in the eggs of exercising female mice, but it was a lot easier for the experimenters to collect sperm from male mice than harvest eggs from the females).
These elevated miRNA changes in the babies soon returned to normal levels if the baby mice did not exercise as they grew. And the grandkids of the original study mice returned to a normal pattern of mouse brain development as would be expected with a similar, unaltered genetic makeup.
Even though this study focused on exercise, we know that other daily activities and exposures can impact miRNA levels, and that miRNA levels can in turn impact other aspects of genetic expression including, for example, cancer development.
It has been speculated that exposure to toxins in our environment (pesticides for example), medications and illicit drug use, and even diet can impact on our miRNA.
Thus, our development (and, in turn, our kids) is not just limited to the genes we inherit from our parents (and their parents).
This means that you can have direct, but limited, control to maximize the benefits of your genes and in turn your genetic contribution to your kids. But for that extra bit of benefit to be passed on to another generation, your kids would also have to adopt a similar “healthy” lifestyle.
And while you are helping give your kids a healthy boost to their genes, you will benefit from this healthy lifestyle. The exercising mice all benefited from a more connected network of nerve cells in their brains which it can be speculated what translates into a decreased tendency to develop Alzheimer’s. And we also have that suspected link between miRNA levels and cancer development.
So, when you are vacillating on that decision to buy the slightly more expensive pesticide free produce at the local QFC, or get out for that all too easy to skip afternoon walk, remember that the decision you make will impact a lot more people than just you.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17413852
Wednesday, May 2, 2018
The Daily Dozen
Every day there seems to be a new research study on healthy eating or lifestyle habits, along with a new diet or exercise recommendation. How can you sort out what’s proven from the “fad” of the week, and then make the necessary changes in your family’s routine.
Dr. Greger (nutritionfacts.org) is a well-known guru of healthy eating who writes an interesting column. He has pulled together a Daily Dozen nutrition and lifestyle tips which he tries to follow. They are all well proven and might give you a place to start if you are interested in changing your own health routine.
It is important to stress that these tips are just a guide, suggestions, and not a list of absolute “must dos”. The Daily Dozen is just a tool to get you started.
It’s interesting to note that Dr. Greger encouraged his family engaged by using an erasable white board on the refrigerator with check boxes for each item. But reaching their daily goal soon became just another piece of the family’s routine and the white board was moved to the garage.
The recommendations are generally food focused with two lifestyle goals as well.
Foods
- Beans (legumes). Legumes are a key to keeping your colon bacteria (the microbiome) happy. You should have three ½ cup servings a day. Split peas, chickpeas, lentils, and tofu count as legumes, as does pea soup and hummus.
- Flax Meal. One tablespoon a day. Flax contains lignans, a potentially anti cancer compound, at a concentration one hundred times higher than other foods. And the other poorly absorbed plant fibers in the flax also help keep that microbiome in balance. Mix the flax meal with applesauce and you can take credit for a fruit serving along with your fiber.
- Berries. One halfalf cup every day. Fresh or frozen. These along with other colored vegetables are loaded with micronutrients and antioxidants.
- Fruit. One medium apple or other piece of fruit (orange, banana, pear) a day. Or substitute one cup of cut up fresh fruit or a half cup of dried fruit.
- Cruciferous vegetables. One half cup a day. Broccoli, cabbage, collards or kale. Cruciferous vegetables contain sulforaphane, which is not found in other green leafy vegetables.
- Greens. Two servings. One serving is a cup of leafy vegetables or half cup cooked such as kale or spinach. And if you had an extra half-cup of broccoli, you can count that as well.
- Other vegetables. Two one-half cup servings. Carrots, asparagus, anything that is not leafy.
- Whole grains. This one is easy in a western diet. One half cup of oatmeal. One half cup of cooked pasta. One tortillas or one slice of bread. Or popcorn (three cups) for an evening snack.
- Nuts. One-quarter cup. A great snack mid morning when you are tempted to open the refrigerator. Peanut butter counts as well!
-
Tumeric. One-quarter
teaspoon. I don’t think its alleged anti cancer properties are as
proven as Dr. Greger’s other recommendations, but I’m including
it as it is his Daily Dozen.
Lifestyle
- Ninety minutes (total per day) of brisk walking or 40 minutes of more intense exercise such as jogging, swimming, or biking. It does not need to be consecutive. You can break it up over the day.
-
Water.
Five glasses. As with the Tumeric, I’ve seen articles
questioning the benefit of five glasses of water.
At first glance, this list looks overwhelming. But when you think about it, a peanut butter sandwich with a banana covers the nuts, fruit and whole grains for the day. And a big salad with a few nuts, tomatoes, and other vegetables covers a lot of ground.
The advantage of starting with a list is that it helps keep things balanced and on track. It reminds you what you may need to buy at the store, and helps with meal planning, especially if you are making dinner and want to add categories you’ve missed during the day. And before long, your choices second nature and the list can go back in the drawer.
If you want to give it a try, there is even a smart phone app called Dr. Greger’s Daily Dozen (in the Apple App Store for sure) that will take the place of that white board or sticky notes on the refrigerator.
References:
https://nutritionfacts.org/video/dr-gregers-daily-dozen-checklist-2/
Sunday, March 25, 2018
First the fat, then it was the salt and now it’s our sugar.
Cut back on your sugar and carbohydrates? Increase the fat in your diet? Ten years ago fat was the killer in our diet and carbohydrates the answer to preventing heart disease, the bane of our fast food society.
Dr. Atkins (of Atkins Diet fame) was one of the
first to suggest that sugar, not fat was the reason for our epidemic
of obesity. A recent review of 23 studies in 2017 supported this
claim with the observation that study participants on a low
carbohydrate diet often lost 2-3 times as much weight as the low fat
groups.
And even more interesting, many of the low carbohydrate group lost weight without any calorie restriction.
And even more interesting, many of the low carbohydrate group lost weight without any calorie restriction.
The appetite suppressing effects of dietary fat
were associated with an unexpected reduction in participants’ total
daily calories. This “fat effect” is why we often take a trip to
the refrigerator within a few hours of a chinese meal (generally low
fat) and can find ourselves skipping that early lunch after a
breakfast of bacon and eggs (high fat).
Then there were the studies showing that excess
sugar increased the risk for heart attacks and strokes. In 2014 the
Journal of the American Medical Association published a study showing
that that North Americans who ate 25 percent of their calories as
sugar had a fatal heart attack rate 2.75 times that of those who ate
less than ten percent as sugar calories.
A meal high in sugar--or a sugared drink--leads to
a rapid rise in blood sugar. Unless that extra sugar is used by
exercising muscles (one of the reasons a good walk after dinner is a
healthy habit), it is converted almost immediately to a type of fat
called triglycerides.
These in turn cause fatty deposits in the lining
of blood vessels and are the reason for the increased risk for a
stroke or heart attack.
Even cancer has been linked to a high sugar diet. Rapidly growing cancer cells get almost all of their energy from sugar in a process that is oxygen-independent, while normal cells get their energy from fats, protein, and sugar in a process that is dependent on oxygen.
This observation led to speculation that the
occasional cancerous cell (resulting from a spontaneous mutation)
would have a better chance of survival in the presence of a high
blood sugar. The theory is supported by a recent study showing an
increased risk of colon cancer recurrence in patients with higher
total daily carbohydrate diets.
Why has it taken so long for this to be sorted
out? That is a story in itself and a great example of why industry
funded research should always be suspect.
In the 1940s there was an ongoing argument in the
medical literature on the role of fats versus sugar as the major risk
factor for heart disease. To quote from an online blog by Dr. Mirkin,
“... in 1965, John Hickson of the Sugar Research Foundation (now
the Sugar Association) wrote to Harvard researchers asking them to
write an article showing that sugar was safe and healthful. He paid
them $6,500 and asked them to review only the research papers
favorable to the sugar industry.”
This was the first step in a cascade of events
that demonized fat and promoted sugar as heart healthy. And it has
taken 50 years for the real facts to come to light.
But the wheel turns and we are now coming back
around to our grandmother’s advice to eat a balanced diet. The
healthiest approach is not an artificially low fat versus low sugar
diet, but instead about eating a balanced diet—a bit of meat,
occasional fish, a side of pasta, and several portions of fruit and
vegetables. And getting rid of that sugar bowl in the kitchen and on
the table.
It won’t be easy. Evidence from PET scans shows
the same brain activity changes with the over consumption of sugar
that we see in drug or tobacco addiction. And when you talk to
someone who has tried to limit the sugar in their diet, their story
reminds you of the withdrawal symptoms described by smokers and
alcoholics. That is several weeks of withdrawal symptoms with a long
term residual urge to have that piece of candy or sugared cereal.
But in their next breath the successful will just
as quickly tell you how much better they feel. So to keep you and
your family healthy, it is time to think about taking that sugar bowl
off the table….and then out of the kitchen.
References
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23136358
Dietary glycemic load and cancer recurrence and survival in patients
with stage III colon cancer: findings from CALGB 89803.
Dietary glycemic load and cancer recurrence and survival in patients
with stage III colon cancer: findings from CALGB 89803.
https://nutritionfacts.org/video/are-sugary-foods-addictive/
http://www.drmirkin.com/heart/added-sugars-linked-to-high-blood-pressure.html
Diabetes and dementia - its the pp blodd sugar. https://www.drmirkin.com/health/diabetes/how-pre-diabetes-increases-risk-for-dementia.html
Tuesday, March 6, 2018
Three tips to jump start that weight loss resolution.
The last few cold days of Winter are here. That can only mean that the longer days of Spring are just around the corner. This is ideal time to see how you’re doing with your New Year’s resolutions, especially that plan to lose a few pounds after the holiday food blitz. If you have been having trouble moving your numbers the right way, these three tips may help you re-energize your program.
Quality over quantity
The traditional approach to weight control (dieting) is based on rigorous portion control and counting calories. Eat fewer calories than you expend each day and watch the dial on the scale plummet. But a recent study suggests that it is the quality of your diet, not quantity is more important.
One study was done to see if there were any advantages of recommending a low fat versus a low carbohydrate diet. Both groups were instructed on cooking and eating nutrient-dense, minimally processed whole foods whenever possible. One group was instructed on low carbohydrate foods and the other on low fat alternatives. Both were asked to try to cut down on portion size, but neither was asked to count calories. At the end of a year both groups lost an equal amount of weight. And participants were most surprised that they did not have to restrict or even think about calories to do so.
The conclusion? Losing weight is not as much about limiting fats or carbohydrates as it is about changing your eating habits to focus on whole foods (those you prepare at home and are not pre-processed and packaged ready to eat).
This may require changes to your lifestyle - more cooking at home, no more quick lunches in the car after a drive-thru lunches at McDonalds - but using whole foods (more vegetables, less added sugar, fewer refined grains) will be healthier as it helps you control your weight.
And after you have shed those unwanted pounds, the same whole food approach, once you have changed your eating habits, is easy to maintain.
No white at night
When you eat the balance of your daily calories is as important to any diet plan as your total daily calories
Calories, especially carbohydrate calories (the “white” foods - bread, pasta, rice) eaten early in the day are metabolized preferentially by active muscles over the following three or four hours. And any carbohydrates not used for immediate energy needs are processed into into fat and stored for future use.
Thus, it makes sense to eat the bulk of your calories early in the day (before 2 PM) when it is most likely you will be up and about at work or doing chores and errands. If you make dinner the big meal of the day, a larger percentage of the meals calories will go directly to fat. If you want to minimize that happening, take a walk (it doesn’t have to be a long one) right after dinner.
A good goal might be a 25-50-25 caloric split for breakfast-lunch-dinner.
Consider fasting
There is solid science behind fasting. An English study compared a traditional calorie restricted diet with one that kept total weekly calories the same but added fasting two days a week (they did allow 700 calories on those two days). Over the three-month study, the average weight loss of the fasting group was twice that of the traditional diet group. And sixty-five percent of those who fasted intermittently lost weight, compared to only 40 percent of those on calorie-restricted diets.
One fasting approach is to adopt a weekly meal plan that includes five days of a normal diet and two “fasting” days.
A second idea would be to modify your daily routine to extended the fasting period to 16 hours (you already have seven or eight while you are sleeping) and then plan your meals for the remaining eight hours. This has been called a 16:8 plan. This is not an absolute and a few bloggers with work shift challenges have suggested that 14:10 works as well.
For an extended daily fasting period, the meal to skip is the late evening meal. When a morning fast was compared to an equivalent evening fast, equal weight was lost, but blood markers of inflammation increased in the morning fast group.
With the daily fast scenario, dieters that move towards two meals a day with just a snack or salad for dinner. One small study compared two groups of women on similar low-calorie diets. One group ate 700 calories for breakfast, 500 for lunch and 200 for dinner, while the other group reversed that with 200 - 500 - 700. Over three months, the large breakfast group lost twice as much weight as the large dinner group.
The message seems clear, eating fewer calories in the evening appears to prove the adage: Eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince and dinner like a pauper.
Monday, January 22, 2018
Cleansing
Feeling a bit low on energy? A
few more headaches than usual? Googling treatment options quickly
leads to websites suggesting you may be suffering from an
accumulation of toxins. And a good cleanse will turn things
right around!
Cleansing has been around since the time of the Egyptians in 1500 BC. In 500 BC, Hippocrates, often referred to as the "Father of Medicine", suggested using enemas for fever therapy.
The benefits of a cleanse are based on the theory of autointoxication. This is the belief that food not absorbed in the upper intestinal tract passes into the colon where bacterial digestion or fermentation occurs (this part of the theiry is true - see my article on the microbiome https://adoctorsrx.blogspot.com.au/2017/06/the-microbome-and-your-health.html ).
But the theory then goes on to postulate the formation of “poisons” which are absorbed into the bloodstream and are a major factor in the development of a variety of chronic disease states.
Cleansing increased in popularity in the early 1900’s until a medical paper in 1919 discounted the theory of autointoxication. When it became clear that the scientific rationale was erroneous, and colonic irrigation was not merely useless but potentially dangerous, the practice was condemned by the American Medical Association as quackery. The practice of cleansing then went into a decline until its resurrection by alternative health providers in the 1990s.
We now know that the multiple bacteria inhabiting the colon, the microbiome, do indeed metabolize unabsorbed carbohydrates, but instead of being poisons, these short chain fatty acids are necessary for our health. They can reduce the inflammation that aggravates arthritis, lower cholesterol, and may prevent certain cancers. This knowledge would suggest that colon cleansers or laxatives would reduce the absorption of these beneficial nutrients.
In 2009, a systematic review of the worldwide medical literature found “no methodologically rigorous controlled trials of colonic cleansing support the practice for general health promotion.” Yet this practice continues to be recommended by alternative medicine providers.
There are two approaches to cleansing - by mouth and by rectum (colonic enemas or lavage). Both may use large volumes of water (up to 16 gallons for a “colonic”). And the solutions often contain other substances such as herbs or coffee.
These procedures are not risk free. Large volumes of fluid, even if just salt water, can lead to major shifts in the body’s water balance (especially risky if you have kidney or heart problems), and the herbal supplements are not without their potential side effects (imagine how you’d feel if you suddenly drank the caffeine equivalent of 3 or 4 Starbuck’s Grande coffees).
And finally there is the risk of actual physical injury from the enema paraphernalia leading to an intestinal infection or even a perforation of the bowel.
In summary
If you feel you are carrying around a colon burdened by bad bacteria and toxins, a safer approach might be an increase in daily fiber (flax is easy) and perhaps a probiotic yogurt to shift the bacterial population.
References:
https://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/9811.html
Cleansing has been around since the time of the Egyptians in 1500 BC. In 500 BC, Hippocrates, often referred to as the "Father of Medicine", suggested using enemas for fever therapy.
The benefits of a cleanse are based on the theory of autointoxication. This is the belief that food not absorbed in the upper intestinal tract passes into the colon where bacterial digestion or fermentation occurs (this part of the theiry is true - see my article on the microbiome https://adoctorsrx.blogspot.com.au/2017/06/the-microbome-and-your-health.html ).
But the theory then goes on to postulate the formation of “poisons” which are absorbed into the bloodstream and are a major factor in the development of a variety of chronic disease states.
Cleansing increased in popularity in the early 1900’s until a medical paper in 1919 discounted the theory of autointoxication. When it became clear that the scientific rationale was erroneous, and colonic irrigation was not merely useless but potentially dangerous, the practice was condemned by the American Medical Association as quackery. The practice of cleansing then went into a decline until its resurrection by alternative health providers in the 1990s.
We now know that the multiple bacteria inhabiting the colon, the microbiome, do indeed metabolize unabsorbed carbohydrates, but instead of being poisons, these short chain fatty acids are necessary for our health. They can reduce the inflammation that aggravates arthritis, lower cholesterol, and may prevent certain cancers. This knowledge would suggest that colon cleansers or laxatives would reduce the absorption of these beneficial nutrients.
In 2009, a systematic review of the worldwide medical literature found “no methodologically rigorous controlled trials of colonic cleansing support the practice for general health promotion.” Yet this practice continues to be recommended by alternative medicine providers.
There are two approaches to cleansing - by mouth and by rectum (colonic enemas or lavage). Both may use large volumes of water (up to 16 gallons for a “colonic”). And the solutions often contain other substances such as herbs or coffee.
These procedures are not risk free. Large volumes of fluid, even if just salt water, can lead to major shifts in the body’s water balance (especially risky if you have kidney or heart problems), and the herbal supplements are not without their potential side effects (imagine how you’d feel if you suddenly drank the caffeine equivalent of 3 or 4 Starbuck’s Grande coffees).
And finally there is the risk of actual physical injury from the enema paraphernalia leading to an intestinal infection or even a perforation of the bowel.
In summary
-
Colon irrigation is
unproven as far as benefits while it has a real risk of adverse
effects.
-
The devices that
practitioners use for the procedure are not approved for colon
cleansing by the US Food and Drug Administration. Inadequately
disinfected or sterilized irrigation machines have been linked to
bacterial contamination.
-
Colon cleansing
practitioners are not licensed by a scientifically based
organization. Rather, practitioners have undergone a training
process structured by an organization that is attempting to
institute its own certification and licensing requirements.
If you feel you are carrying around a colon burdened by bad bacteria and toxins, a safer approach might be an increase in daily fiber (flax is easy) and perhaps a probiotic yogurt to shift the bacterial population.
References:
https://www.drmirkin.com/morehealth/9811.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)